2025 NFL Trade Deadline: RB Scarcity Creating Fantasy Chaos

With Austin Ekeler, James Conner, and Najee Harris all suffering season-ending injuries, running back scarcity is at an all-time high. Here's how to navigate the Nov. 4 trade deadline.

The RB Injury Crisis Has Hit Hard

The 2025 season has been brutal for running backs, creating unprecedented scarcity that's reshaping fantasy landscapes everywhere. Three cornerstone backs—Austin Ekeler (fractured tibia), James Conner (torn ACL), and Najee Harris (high ankle sprain, IR)—are all done for the season. This isn't just bad luck; it's a fantasy football catastrophe that's forcing managers to completely rethink their roster construction strategies.

The Numbers Don't Lie:

• 12 starting RBs currently on IR or out indefinitely
• Waiver wire RB pickups at 87% ownership rate (highest in 5 years)
• Top 24 RB scoring average has dropped from 16.8 PPG to 14.2 PPG

Trade Deadline Value Shift: What It Means For You

RB Trade Value Has Skyrocketed 📈

Elite RB1s Now Worth:

• Christian McCaffrey: 1.5x normal value
• CMC is averaging 23.5 PPG and is the only consistent workhorse back
• Trade packages requiring: RB1 + 2nd round pick OR WR1 + WR2

Mid-Tier RB2s Now Worth:

• James Cook: 1.3x normal value after Week 8 explosion
• Breece Hall: Increased 40% in value despite recent struggles
• Saquon Barkley: Top-5 ROS value despite age concerns

Buy Low Targets Before Value Normalizes:

• Travis Etienne Jr. - Only 58% rostered, seeing 18+ touches weekly
• Zach Charbonnet - Taking over lead duties in Seattle, 72% snap share last two games
• Tony Pollard Jr. - PPR machine in New England, 89% route participation

Sell High Before the Correction

Overvalued Assets to Move:

• Dillon Gabriel - Coming off career game but faces brutal schedule
• Isiah Pacheco - Name value exceeding production, only 3.6 YPC
• Jordan Mason - Beneficiary of McCaffrey's dominance, unsustainable role

The Trade Strategy Blueprint

If You're RB Strong: Leverage Your Advantage

Don't hoard RBs—sell them for WR1 upgrades or premium draft picks.

Example trade package:

Your: RB2 (like James Cook) + Flex RB
Their: WR1 (like Ja'Marr Chase) + 2nd Round 2026 Pick

Target these WRs in RB-for-WR trades:

• A.J. Brown (underperforming, buy-low opportunity)
• Garrett Wilson (schedule toughens, sell-high before drop)
• Tee Higgins (breakout candidate, perfect sell-high target)

If You're RB Needy: Be Aggressive But Smart

Don't panic overpay—find the right deal.

Trade Away These Overvalued Assets:

• Streaming QBs with favorable schedules past
• Underperforming WR2s with name recognition
• Late-round draft picks for immediate RB help

Focus on Volume, Not Name Recognition:

• Tyjae Spears - Taking over Derrick Henry's role gradually
• Kendre Miller - Alvin Kamara's direct backup in New Orleans
• Blake Corum - Next man up in LA if Kyren Williams goes down

Deadline Trade Targets: Week 9 Edition

Must-Buy RBs 🎯

1. Tyrone Tracy Jr. (NYG)

   • 67% rostered, climbing fast
   • 12-team PPR league must-add
   • Has 20+ touch upside weekly

2. Zach Charbonnet (SEA)

   • Direct handcuff to Kenneth Walker
   • 72% snap share last two games
   • Schedule: NE, ARI, SF, MIN (very favorable)

3. Travis Etienne Jr. (JAX)

   • Still under 60% rostered somehow
   • 18+ touches every game
   • PPR floor of 12 points weekly

Sell-High Candidates 💰

1. Dillon Gabriel (NE)

   • Career high vs Jets (32.4 points)
   • Next 4: MIA, BUF, BAL, PIT (nightmare)
   • Trade now before value crashes

2. Isiah Pacheco (KC)

   • Name value > actual production
   • Only 3.6 YPC, TDs coming from vultures
   • Move while you still can

Playoff Push Strategy

Week 9-12 RB Schedule Analysis:

Most Favorable Playoff RB Schedules:

1. James Cook (BUF): MIA, IND, SF, LAC
2. Saquon Barkley (PHI): CAR, ARI, NYG, BAL
3. Tony Pollard Jr. (NE): CHI, CHI, SEA, IND

Toughest Remaining Schedules:

1. Dillon Gabriel (NE): MIA, BUF, BAL, PIT
2. Breece Hall (NYJ): ARI, NE, SEA, GB
3. Josh Jacobs (LV): CIN, BAL, MIN, KC

The Trade Deadline Checklist

Before Making Any Trade:

✅ Check Schedule Strength - Use our Schedule Analyzer ✅ Verify Team Health - Check injury reports daily ✅ Assess Playoff Needs - Do you need floor or ceiling? ✅ Evaluate Trade Market - Know your league's specific values

Execute Your Plan:

1. Identify 3 Target Players
2. Calculate fair trade value
3. Send offers to multiple managers
4. Be willing to counter-offer
5. Complete trades by Nov 22

The Bottom Line

RB scarcity is here to stay through the 2025 season. The managers who adjust their strategies and make aggressive moves now will dominate the fantasy playoffs. Don't be the manager stuck with a depleted RB corps when Week 14 arrives.

Use our trade analyzer to get professional-grade analysis on any deal before making your move. The difference between a championship and an early playoff exit often comes down to one strategic trade at the deadline.

---

This analysis reflects Week 9, 2025 NFL data. For the most current player values and trade recommendations, use our AI-powered trade analyzer to get personalized advice based on your specific roster and league settings.